Paul McAnulty hit .310 over 125 games in Triple-A with 34 doubles, five triples, 19 homers and 79 RBI's. He also scored 76 runs while drawing 62 walks playing first base, third base and left and right field. 2005

McAnulty hit .282 with 17 doubles, two triples, ten homers, 42 RBI's and 39 runs scored in 79 games for the Mobile BayBears in 2005.

McAnulty hit .344 with 15 doubles, six homers, 27 RBI's and 27 runs scored in 38 games for the Portland Beavers in 2005. He also drew 16 walks and struck out 29 times for a .405 OBP.

2004

MadFriars.com Batter of the Year. With the Storm, McAnulty hit .297 with 23 homers and 85 RBI's. He walked 88 times, which tied for the Cal League lead. He also smacked 36 doubles and scored 93 runs. He was sent up to Mobile for the playoffs and batted .471 in four games to help lead them to the Southern League Championship.

Selected in the 12th round of the 2002 First-Year Player Draft.

McAnulty led Long Beach with nine homers and 55 RBIs along with a .610 slugging percentage, while batting .360 in his only season with the Dirtbags.

2002–Won the Pioneer League batting title (.379) in his first professional season at Idaho Falls.