MLB Rankings: Bullpens
Neftali Feliz
Neftali Feliz
MadFriars.com
Posted May 23, 2010
Denis Savage


Not enough credit is given to the major league bullpen. Oftentimes, they are the reason a team wins or loses. A solid ‘pen can be the difference between a team fighting for a playoff spot and one that is trying to stay out of last place.

Best Bullpens In Baseball

A solid bullpen is more than just a closer. Today’s game demands a plethora of arms to keep the game tight from the fifth inning on. When you have the ‘pen, the opposition can be deflated, knowing they will be hard pressed to score in the late innings.

American League

1. Detroit Tigers

Jose Valverde has been dynamite as the closer. Ryan Perry an emerging young reliever. Eddie Bonine the key long man. Joel Zumaya is throwing bullets. Phil Coke was a steal from the Yankees. There aren’t many misses in this group – each with their own flair and ability.

“If our bullpen continues to perform as they have all year, we have an excellent chance to compete,” Tigers general manager Dave Dombrowski said.

2. Texas Rangers

Placing Neftali Feliz in as the closer was the one that put this squad over the top. Darren O’Day might be the most undervalued reliever in the sport. Darren Oliver has been his usual trustworthy self. Chris Ray is a former closer that is back to full strength after health issues. It is a team built for the trenches.

3. New York Yankees

How do you compete with Mariano Rivera and his cutter? You don’t. Joba Chamberlain has a defined role to thrive, displaying a lot of confidence with the clarity of his assignment. They have assembled a quality crew with Sergio Mitre and Damaso Marte providing more stability.

National League

1. San Diego Padres

Wins are in the BAG with the combination of Heath Bell, Mike Adams and Luke Gregerson. Bell is proving he is no one-year wonder. Adams could be a closer for some teams. Gregerson may be the most impressive of the bunch. That doesn’t take into account Tim Stauffer (on the DL) – the long man – who had a 17.1-inning scoreless streak.

2. St. Louis Cardinals

Moving back to the bullpen saved Ryan Franklin’s career. The right-hander has been a reliable part of a great bullpen. Only one pitcher who has appeared in at least 10 games has an ERA over 4.00. Kyle McClellan and Jason Motte are two emerging youngsters while veteran Dennys Reyes has yielded just three hits in 12.1 innings through May 22.

3. Colorado Rockies

With Huston Street and Franklin Morales out, the Rockies have continued to find arms to keep them in the game. Manuel Corpas has performed well as the closer. Matt Belisle has posted zeroes, often over multiple innings. Joe Beimel is crafty and knows how to get hitters out with consistency. When Street and Morales return, this unit looks even more formidable.

Worst Bullpens In Baseball

The eyes glisten, the saliva begins to drip, the chops are licked. Hitters feast on poor pitching in the back half of a game. Knowing a bullpen is weak, hitters are more apt to work the count early to get to the trouble spots. These teams need help if they are to remain competitive.

American League

1. Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim

When Fernando Rodney is your most reliable option, things can’t be good. Scot Shields – a sure thing of the past – suddenly looks his age. Brian Stokes wishes he was back in the NL. Jason Bulger and Kevin Jepsen can throw hard but lack command. Things could get worse before they get better.

2. Baltimore Orioles

Alfredo Simon has stabilized the closer spot. The addition of Koji Uehara has helped. Will Ohman has reverted to 2005 form but the more recent past has to be truer to form, right? There is no player that the team feels comfortable getting that big out, especially their lack of success in keeping inherited runners from scoring.

3. Cleveland Indians

The Indians have something in Chris Perez – he was bred as a closer and is an emerging talent. Getting Kerry Wood back may have been a curse to the bullpen. They have a lot of young players that are maturing quickly in Mitch Talbot and Tony Sipp. Another year and this bullpen could quickly ascend to the upper tier. With their rotation, it may be asking too much of this group.

National League

1. Arizona Diamondbacks

The loss of Valverde was a lot bigger than most would have believed. Aaron Heilman has been their best option. Mets and Cubs fans can tell you how well that worked out. He is the lone pitcher with an ERA under 4.95. Chad Qualls is better than the numbers but is likely feeling he must do everything. He needs help. The unit has surrendered more homers than any other bullpen in baseball.

2. Milwaukee Brewers

A man with 596 saves doesn’t get there without an abundance of talent. This year, Trevor Hoffman has blown as many as he has saved and looks less than ordinary. Has time finally caught up with the 42-year-old? LaTroy Hawkins has been terrible as well. Manny Parra might have the most electric arm but remains inconsistent.

3. Pittsburgh Pirates

Without Evan Meek, who has been outstanding, the Pirates pen is in shambles. While the unit can rack of the strikeouts, they also issue a large number of free passes. They are second in the majors in innings pitched and not contributing with consistency.

Final Musings:

  • One of the top bullpens early in the year has been the New York Mets. This was a big question mark coming in. Jenrry Mejia has been electric but should be a starter. Francisco Rodriguez will drive fans insane. As a whole, they have been quite effective but the question permeates – will it last?
  • Hard to believe how good the Minnesota Twins bullpen has performed without anchor Joe Nathan. It was believed they would have to trade for bullpen help, but the club has performed well with relative unknowns plugging the gaps and Jon Rauch closing the door with effectiveness.
  • The bullpen stats of the Chicago Cubs have been blown up by a select few. There are question marks – mostly on the mental side with Carlos Marmol and Carlos Zambrano – but the talent level is hard to deny. Pulling the correct strings is Lou Piniella’s job.
  • Any team with Jonathan Papelbon can’t be as bad as it has been early in the year. Hideki Okajima hasn’t been good and other veterans have also struggled for the Boston Red Sox. They have too much talent for that to last and should bounce back.
  • ===========================
    Want more in-depth coverage on your favorite MLB team? Click Here and get started today.

    Join Denis Savage on Twitter at Denis Savage of MadFriars.com



    Related Stories
    Giants Prospect Meter: Who’s Hot
     -by DiamondbacksDaily.com  May 22, 2010
    Missions lose in 13
     -by MadFriars.com  May 22, 2010
    Padres Minor League Notebook: 5-22-10
     -by MadFriars.com  May 22, 2010

    PREMIUM SUBSCRIPTION INCLUDES
    > Members-only Forums
    > Insider Information
    > MiLB &
       MLB Draft News
    > Expert Chats

    Sign Up Today!

    Free Email Newsletter
    Don't miss any news or features from MadFriars.com. Subscribe to our newsletter to have our newest articles emailed to you on a daily or weekly basis.
    Click here for a list of all Team Newsletters.